States Speculate on the Midterms and BEAD
Yesterday, after dropping off my mail ballot in my town, I came home and instead of thinking about whether my chosen candidates would win, I started thinking about BEAD. Seriously. This may be a cry for help.
I took some time to get on the phone and start calling state broadband office (SBO) directors across the country, asking them to speculate what could happen with BEAD post-election.
I reached a little more than ten and while many declined to comment because, well… these are the times we live in where blowback is seen not just as possible, but likely.
Others simply hadn’t thought about it as the deployment phase of BEAD is underway and, at the very least, mapped out.
Of those I spoke to about the midterms, each assumed that at least the House would turn blue/go to Democrats.
Non-Deployment No Longer Nonexistent?
The views on the ~$20B in ‘savings’ ranged from optimism to pessimism.
Most agreed that a blue chamber would perform oversight meetings to examine what’s happening not only with the deployment, but also the non-deployment dollars.
One pessimistic SBO lead said that other than an accountability check, not much will change. Another was more hopeful about hearings:
“I think there are Democrats and probably Republicans that are going to be interested in hearing about BEAD and putting pressure on NTIA. The dems are going to be calling NTIA in front of them and say… Where the hell are we with this $20 billion… the non-deployment dollars remaining. What have you been doing?”
Another lead pointed to campaign promises and a lack of effectiveness in bringing investments into states. Each election brings pressure on representatives and senators to bring back state investment. The lead speculates that handing out already allocated dollars would be a big win for anyone who wins office:
“Discourse has brought to light a lack of federal common sense and execution of commitments. We have a $20B program that’s effectively been hijacked. I don't know if stolen is too hard of a word, but I also don't know what a better word would be.”
Another SBO lead expressed fears that a change in House leadership and hearings would distract the NTIA.
“Each minute that Arielle Roth and Secretary Lutnick spend in a congressional inquiry is one less minute they have to publish non-deployment guidance.”
And one wondered if the pressure that democrats could put on the NTIA to ‘do something’ could result in a half-assed solution.
“If we see a big swing in the midterms I think the NTIA gets more pressure on non-deployment and we could get a half-baked piece of guidance on what all states can use it for, but it will still be greatly tilted towards this administration’s priorities including terms AI and data centers.”
The most pessimistic view of an SBO lead probably aligns with my thoughts best:
“I think the Department of Commerce is trying to set it up to have it both ways. If it breaks to the right, Republicans will do a rescission to get rid of all the non-deployment money. And if it goes left, then the NTIA comes out with guidance and say that they were always going to give the money out, regardless.”
Digital Capacity (Equity)
A larger state’s lead told me that they anticipate that a change in leadership would…
“…bring back what we were hoping to do with digital capacity/equity. It could make it a reality and facilitate digital training and workforce development.”
Another, more cynical SBO lead also sees a possible resuscitation as an olive branch from the NTIA, an issue that would be easy to give in to while they push back on others.
“I think we get more pressure for digital equity to get back to the states. I could see the NTIA deciding to be much more interested in releasing both the Digital Equity Act monies and the non-deployment guidance because there will be lots of discussions as to what are things worth defending and what are things not.”
Governors Matter
One leader told me that a majority of changes could come, not from the Congress, but from governors’ offices. Thirty-six are in play on Tuesday, with many expected to change hands.
It could have an impact on non-deployment as far as what priorities are and if we can move forward or if we need NTIA guidance first. I think you might see some state priorities change with changes in governors.
And in the end…
One lead looked beyond my question of who gets elected and took a bigger picture, historical perspective.
“There are typically cabinet changes after midterms and the biggest change could be the head of Commerce [Howard Lutnick]. His removal could break the logjam on non-deployment, because that's where the logjam is coming from right now.”
Is BEAD red or is it blue? Or neither? We may see in the coming weeks.
Views expressed are the author’s own and do not necessarily represent the official position of broadband.io or its affiliates. Contact Doug Adams at doug@broadbandmarketers.com with any comments or questions.