Researchers find ISPs overreported service to rural areas after receiving Connect America Fund $$$

A new study from UC Santa Barbara shows that the FCC’s Connect America Fund (CAF) didn’t live up to its lofty goals when it came to boosting internet access in rural areas.

For those not in the industry at the time, the CAF was established in late 2011 by FCC when Obama was president, designed to provide $4.5 billion in federal funding to “extend broadband infrastructure to the millions of Americans who currently have no access to broadband.”

Now, 13 years later, after analyzing data from 537,000 addresses across 15 states, researchers at UCSB found that only 55% of addresses that were supposed to have service from the CAF actually did.

Worse yet, just 33% of these locations met the minimum speed requirements set by the FCC.

The study used a tool the researchers developed previously called the Broadband Plan Querying Tool (BQT) to compare what ISPs reported to what they actually offered. Turns out, some big players like AT&T and Frontier weren’t living up to their promises. In some states, like New Jersey, AT&T had a shocking 0% service rate at the addresses they were supposed to cover!

What went wrong? Trusting a single ISP to serve an area as a monopoly seems to be one part of it:

“The CAF program operates by establishing a regulated monopoly in underserved communities. In locations where no provider offers service, CAF grants infrastructure subsidies to a single ISP on the condition that it agrees to serve that location. To mitigate concerns that such a subsidized monopolist may charge monopoly prices or offer substandard service, CAF mandates that the broadband plans offered at subsidized locations satisfy certain rate and service conditions”

…despite benefiting financially from the CAF program, these ISPs do not comply with the FCC’s service availability and quality terms, leaving many targeted rural communities with no or substandard Internet connectivity.”

The findings are a wake-up call as the government rolls out the $42.5 billion Broadband Equity Access and Deployment (BEAD) program. The researchers emphasize that we need better oversight to ensure this massive investment doesn’t go to waste. For policymakers and rural communities alike, the message is clear: we need more transparency and real accountability to close the digital divide.

As they write:

“Indeed, federal and state officials should consider past compliance with funding programs such as CAF when deciding how to allocate new funds…Specifically, the post-hoc evaluation framework developed in this paper could be readily applied to the BEAD program, which is poised to spend over $ 42 billion.”

Without them, billions could be wasted, and rural communities could stay stuck on the wrong side of the digital divide.

For more details, check out the full study (attached below).

What do you think, Broadband.IOers? Surprised by the results? Were you working in the industry when the CAF was unveiled and what do you think about this study and its conclusions about why CAF failed to deliver on its goals?

3651890.3672272.pdf