Pennsylvania alone among states to modify anti-municipal language in BEAD proposals

Remember the language in the Notice of Funding Opportunity that said municipalities won’t be prejudiced from using Infrastructure Act funds just because their states have restrictions on communities running broadband networks?

Turns out that it’s a little bit harder to implement than simply the National Telecommunciations and Information Administration saying so.

Pennsylvania stands alone on clarifying BEAD plan

According to City & State Pennsylvania, the state stands alone – among those that restrict municipal broadband – in clarifying how municipalities will be able to participate in the Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment grant program of NTIA.

Meanwhile, Pennsylvania has adjusted its initial draft plan to clarify how it would approach the existing state law. 

Under its public utility code, the commonwealth prohibits local governments from providing broadband in areas where a telephone company like AT&T offers internet service. But the Department of Community and Economic Development Department has said that while adhering to federal and state law, it would seek to work with and distribute funds to municipalities to meet local broadband needs. 

“PBDA anticipates engaging with a variety of entities, including for-profit internet service providers, nonprofits, cooperatives, and local governments to achieve affordable, high-speed internet for all Pennsylvanians,” Brandon Carson, executive director of the Pennsylvania Broadband Development Authority, said in a statement. “PBDA views this as an opportunity to partner with BEAD subgrantees to navigate the necessary commonwealth processes and achieve compliance with both state and federal laws.”

At Broadband Breakfast, we reported in May about how the Colorado legislature and governor changed the state’s law regarding community broadband":

Colorado Law for Muni Broadband Networks, VETRO and COS Collaborate, South African Open Access

Colorado Gov. Jared Polis on May 1, 2023, signed a bill giving the state’s local governments greater flexibility in creating municipal broadband networks.

With his signing of bill S.B. 183, Colorado removed a significant speedbump for many municipalities seeking to build local broadband networks.

More broadly, according to the report by Kerry Murakami of Route Fifty, Nevada and Texas are among 16 states that bar or restrict municipal broadband, and they do not appear to have budged.

Could the feds withhold broadband funding to some states?

Nevada’s BEAD proposal, despite the infrastructure law’s requirement, says that “municipalities and counties that do not meet the population requirements will not be eligible to get the funding.”

In its draft plan, Texas’ broadband office said only the state’s legislature can change a law that gives preference to private broadband providers. As a result, the office said it cannot allow local governments to be eligible for BEAD funding in areas where private companies are also seeking funding to improve broadband service.

Looking to prior NTIA statements on the topic

NTIA Doing All it Can to 'Pressure' States to Allow Municipal Broadband for Infrastructure Builds

Here’s the language that NTIA Administrator Alan Davidson had in May 2022 about municipalities and broadband:

The National Telecommunications and Information Administration is using all available tools to “pressure” states to allow municipal broadband to be used for infrastructure builds stemming from funding in the bipartisan infrastructure bill.

Several states have laws prohibiting municipal broadband networks, which through its recently released notice of funding the NTIA is recommending be waived for upcoming infrastructure builds.

“We are gonna press states to make sure they are doing everything they can do under their laws to make, to be including those,” said Davidson.

What do you think about the approach by Colorado, Pennsylvania, Nevada and Texas? Is there any way to challenge or address states that won’t allow BEAD funds to be used by public entities?