Meet Ramón Hobdey-Sánchez

BEAD Efforts in Idaho are No Small Potatoes

When I first met Idaho’s Broadband Director, Ramón Hobdey-Sánchez, it was late 2023 when he was on the cusp of adding to his broadband office of just himself. As the only member of Idaho’s Office of Broadband (IOB), he relied on members of the state’s Commerce Department to help him with tasks, large and small, including the allocation of ARPA/CPF funds.  

Idaho’s portion of CPF for broadband was $120 million and went to 15 grant winners to fund 18 separate projects. With cash and in-kind matches, funding for projects became $178.8 million to reach ~35K Idaho BSLs.  

Hobdey-Sánchez tells broadband.io that fiber made up ~75% of CPF projects and that he’s “feeling really good about the projects as some are nearing completion, others are making great progress, and the last few are getting ready to break ground.” 

“One of our positive stories with the Idaho CPF Program was just the number of public-private-partnerships that emerged,” explains Hobdey-Sánchez. “ISPs work directly with local jurisdictions, and we're seeing the fruits of those partnerships coming to fruition.”

With BEAD, Ramón’s No Longer Living in His Own Private Idaho 

Before looking at the future, let’s look back at the volume of work required to be ready to launch BEAD this summer for Hobdey-Sánchez and his team of five. 

In May (pre 6/6 Lutnick guidance/nuclear bomb), Idaho had announced 40 applicants successfully navigated the prequalification application phase. Idaho was on the precipice of opening the funding application phase, which Hobdey-Sánchez tells me would have “knocked out the entire BSL list with fiber and all technologies being accepted, with fiber projects receiving extra points in the evaluation phase.” 

“Our prequal list has fiber, fixed wireless, and LEO providers. Because we needed to cover so many locations with the $583 million, we always knew that there was going to be a healthy mix of technology types in Idaho to get this accomplished,” says Hobdey-Sánchez.

What Now Idaho?

One development from the June 6 BEAD guidance is that locations served by unlicensed fixed wireless could/would take some BSLs off the map for BEAD eligibility. 

Currently, Idaho just wrapped up its 7-day window for notification from unlicensed carriers, who will submit evidence that BSLs are served and should be taken off the BEAD map. Hobdey-Sánchez tells me that preliminary analysis of unlicensed fixed wireless coverage could mean that up to ~19K BSLs are taken off the BEAD eligibility map which currently stands at ~94K. He hopes to have vetted the submissions and have the final numbers sorted out after July 1, and ready to submit by the feds’ modified BSL deadline of July 7. 

In the IIJA/fiber-first/pre-June 6 world, Hobdey-Sánchez said Idaho was expecting approximately 60% fiber, 20% fixed wireless and then 20% ‘other.’ 

Since June 6, Hobdey-Sánchez says that he hasn’t heard much from any fiber or licensed fixed-wireless providers. But who he has heard from is Idaho’s unlicensed fixed wireless providers, as they can “fully participate and engage in the BEAD Program.”

Now or Later? Why not BOTH? 

While Hobdey-Sánchez concedes that the new guidance could be a “positive in terms of short-term success,” he’s cautiously optimistic about that there could be “downfalls when we look at this 20, 30, 40 years from now.” 

He muses that investment in some alternative technologies could be efficient and effective today, and even more affordable… “but what about just simple lifespan [of the technologies]?” 

Pressed to guess where fiber projects might land as a percentage when BEAD is complete, Hobdey-Sánchez says that while it would have originally been about a 60/40 split between fiber and other technologies, “I think it could probably flip to 40% fiber and then 60% other or alternative technologies.” 

One reason Hobdey-Sánchez is optimistic fiber will stay a significant portion of the projects is that prior to the new guidance, fiber providers were going to have the option to exclude hard-to-reach BSLs within a project area. “A fiber provider could look at a project area and say, I want to do this all fiber, but 3% of these locations are going to blow the budget out, so we need to partner with LEOs or some other technology. These partnerships were already in the works.” 

Idaho’s K-Mart Blue Light Special Round 

Hobdey-Sánchez says he has spoken with the NTIA regarding how much of the 90 days that the ’Benefit of the Bargain’ round should take. “We're likely looking at maybe a two-week window. I have been told the duration has to be ‘reasonable’ and that one week would be on the short end of reasonable.” 

Reflecting on the Guidance 

Rather than asking Hobdey-Sánchez what HE thought about the changes, I asked him what he’s been hearing from his peers. He tells me that “…there's some frustration because a lot of these decisions were made in a top-down fashion, changing a state-led program to one that states don’t and didn’t have a lot of input into as it relates to the new guidelines. When you speak with some directors who must redo their hard work, have already ran subgrantee selection, and have already done provisional awards… that's hurts a lot more.”

“Several state broadband directors had a vision of what they wanted to do with this program,” Hobdey-Sánchez said, “and now that's out the window.” 

“But we've all been working hard on this for a long time, and now we're going to get this done and we're going to get it done as effectively and efficiently as possible. And 90 days may sound aggressive, but we've got some really strong state offices that will make this work,” says Hobdey-Sánchez. 

Napolean Ramón Dynamite 

Given the years of investment and the current, sudden changes, I asked Hobdey-Sánchez why he would undertake such a massive challenge. He tells me that “…these types of projects are passion projects. Many of us have dedicated our entire professional careers to public service and you don't always get an opportunity to work on such an awesome project that could have a historical impact on a region or a community.”

No matter how BEAD shakes out, Hobdey-Sánchez reminds me of all the great work his office has already done to-date, including middle-mile projects (funded by the Idaho Broadband Fund) as well as connecting 35K through CPF and thousands more prior to that via the CARES Act.

I’ve had conversations with people in the office here as well as across the state and I tell them what I sincerely believe, “don't worry, we're going to get this figured out. I'm optimistic in terms of the connections we're going to be able to make, and we're going to try our best to stretch those dollars to connect folks.”