Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas tries to find out if least connected states are getting broadband ...

In the first of a three-part series on digital inclusion, four authors at the Dallas Federal Reserve Bank — Marycruz De Leon, Kassandra Huhn, Prithvi Kalkunte and Xiaohan Zhang —explore how well the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) funding does at helping states with broadband gaps.

Some findings:

Data Challenges and Sources: IIJA provides $65 billion for broadband investments through various grant programs. Accurate data on broadband gaps is crucial, yet inconsistent datasets from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), Ookla, and the Census Bureau pose challenges.

Each dataset has its strengths and limitations, impacting the understanding of broadband needs. The FCC data, based on provider reports, may not reflect actual connection speeds. Ookla’s Speedtest data, reflecting user experience, may be biased toward users with internet access. The Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (ACS) provides consistent data but lacks detail on broadband speed and coverage in group quarters and workplaces.

Overlap and Discrepancies: A comparison of the top 10 states with the greatest broadband demand based on these datasets shows only four states (Montana, Mississippi, Alaska, and Wyoming) consistently ranking high. Discrepancies between FCC and Ookla data highlight the need for a synthesized measure combining all three sources.

Funding Distribution: IIJA funding generally aligns with broadband gaps, though some inconsistencies remain. The top 10 states for per capita funding include Alaska, Montana, West Virginia, Wyoming, New Mexico, Mississippi, Vermont, Arkansas, South Dakota, and Missouri. While funding per capita matches broadband needs, it doesn’t account for geographic spread, which is crucial for rural areas where costs to connect remote locations can be very high. The total cost of deploying high-quality national infrastructure exceeds current IIJA funding, suggesting a need for additional investment to meet future broadband needs.

Next Installments: The second part of the series will examine the details of each IIJA grant category and the variations across states, focusing on New Mexico, Louisiana, and Texas. The final part will discuss common barriers in the competitive grant process and how digital inclusion leaders can support communities.