Six Questions for VCBB’s Christine Hallquist
@Christine Hallquist, executive director of Vermont Community Broadband Board, is a former Vermont gubernatorial candidate and the first openly transgender major party nominee for a gubernatorial election, has been at the forefront of expanding equitable access to broadband and electricity for decades. She was previously the CEO of the Vermont Electric Cooperative and was the subject of the 2016 documentary directed by her son, Denial, which documents her transition while serving as CEO.
Hallquist appeared on the broadband community’s latest episode of its Ask Me Anything! series.
The questions and answers below have been edited and condensed for clarity and length.
What sparked an interest in expanding broadband access and working with the Vermont Community Broadband Board?
Hallquist, the daughter of an electrical engineer, became interested in electrical engineering by accompanying him to work. She struggled through high school before thriving at Mohawk Valley Community College where she studied electrical, electronic and communications engineering technology. She later joined the Digital Equipment Corporation as a technician.
By 2000, Hallquist was hired by Vermont Electric Cooperative to assist them as they exited bankruptcy, and eventually became CEO. During her tenure as CEO, she worked to raise awareness about climate change and build an infrastructure to increase climate resiliency as a priority for the organization, raising the eyebrows and frustrations of her board.
During this time, she became interested in building fiber networks as a greener alternative to wireless and cable networks. Hallquist, through searching for a greener alternative, realized that both goals of expanding internet access and preparing for climate change were intertwined.
Will the funds that Vermont received through the American Rescue Plan Act be enough to bring fiber to every home and business in Vermont?
Vermont’s total cost to expand broadband access to unserved and underserved populations will be about $650 million, Hallquist said, with the state currently having around $500 million budgeted between ARPA dollars and funding from the state legislature. The remaining amount will come from business plans sponsored by municipal bonds.
Vermont’s position as a semi-rural state means that more remote customers will not be served by fiber. Despite this, Christine emphasized that fiber should be considered the standard, and that Wireless is not feasible beyond a handful of remote customers because of its latency delays and climate change concerns.
“Putting a wireless antenna on a hill in Vermont and thinking you’re going to serve people in Vermont is just not possible,” Hallquist said. “We’re more than 80% trees so in the summer it drops off considerably and there’s so many pockets that you just can’t get to.”
How did the Vermont Community Broadband Board come into existence?
It came into existence with Act 71 , which was signed by Governor Phil Scott in July 2021, that created the ability for two towns to partner in building a CUD, or communications union district. As of today, 216 of 252 towns are now part of CUDs that cover around 96% of the state’s unserved/underserved locations and, in part due to the legislations, towns can now form their own CUDs with a public or private telecommunications partner as long as they present a universal service plan.
Communications Union Districts are a unique strategy that has taken off in Vermont as a means of solving the state’s broadband shortage. How has this worked and what’s the VCCB’s role in this?
CUDs are community-owned, public-private networks that can either provide their own service or white-label for a private provider. The key here is that they operate autonomously and present their plans to the VCBB who provides feedback and approves these individual plans.
VCCB’s structure is as an agency housed in the Public Services Department. Its leadership is appointed by the governor and reports to a separate board which has 2 appointments by the governor, one appointment by the State House, one appointment by the State Senate and another by the CUDs. The organization, meanwhile, resides in the Public Service department to save time and money for building a new agency while also taking advantage of numerous strategic partnership opportunities.
Has the potential for climate change affected your strategy of expanding broadband throughout Vermont?
Vermont is in the midst of a historic flood currently with flood watches remaining in effect through Sunday night, according to local sources. Hallquist says that fiber is essential in the fight against climate change as it allows people to use renewable products, plug in cars and respond to outages. Fiber also allows for the development of a smart grid which allows for a more accurate picture of remote geographical areas and faster response times.
A middle mile design is currently underway along with geographic redundancy design throughout Vermont’s networks with every hub being fed by two fiber feeds and having connections with Canada, Massachusetts, New York and New Hampshire, as well.
What’s the biggest challenge in measuring (and improving) the state of broadband access in Vermont?
A massive hurdle to expanding broadband access in Vermont is the FCC’s map which has contained numerous inaccuracies and has been challenged by numerous states, including Vermont. BEAD funding is restricted to addresses that are on the map as being unserved or underserved making challenges to the FCC map so crucial.
The root cause of the problem is how the FCC sets up broadband expansion. There’s telecommunications providers who report the speeds that you can get as a consumer with the onus being on the consumer to report speed inconsistencies. Until the FCC changes this, Hallquist said, we’ll be forced to advocate about these inconsistencies and probably won’t ever get them right.
The whole process should be changed to require telecommunications providers to disclose monthly reports by address of speeds and service quality similar to public utility companies, Hallquist said.