Virginia versus SpaceX

In what could be considered a predictable measure, SpaceX took the opportunity to express concern in Virginia’s 7-day comment period for its revised Final Proposal for BEAD. SpaceX is aggrieved that they were chosen for only 5,579 of Virginia’s now 133K BSLs.

The seven-page complaint/comment from SpaceX posits that the Virginia Broadband Office, for the most part, ignored the Benefit of the Bargain guidelines from the NTIA’s June 6th revised guideline. SpaceX says it applied for ‘nearly all of these locations [BSLs]’ but was unfairly limited to receive ‘only 3.6% of the locations’ included in its application.

While expressing concern over unfair treatment of its LEO applications, there is no mention in SpaceX’s comments that Amazon’s Kuiper also received 6,957 BSLs. Between Kuiper and SpaceX, LEO will receive 9.86% of BEAD-eligible BSLs. This equates to 1.6% of allocated BEAD dollars to serve these BSLs LEO. In all, Virginia saved $200 million in the ‘Benefit of the Bargain’ round.

Accusing Virginia of “disregarding the Trump Administration’s effort to restructure the program to accelerate broadband deployment and reduce spending,” SpaceX seems to be more concerned with the “massive waste of federal taxpayer money” than the fact that there are questions about LEOs scalability and ability to serve more than (approximately) 10% of BSLs.

A data point the Vernonburg Group cited in its own submitted comments stated that SpaceX’s capacity is aligned with the award it received. Their analysis is that “10%... would be the capacity range for unserved and underserved locations, which was between 5.2% and 16.4%.”

On the other end of the spectrum of comments, several citizens were dismayed that they would receive LEO instead of fiber. Citizen comments included:

“This program was meant to bridge the divide that we face in rural areas but without support for fiber programs from government funds, no company will ever update the infrastructure in my area to truly put us on a level playing field. As the rest of Virginia gets future proof options, we in Pound [county] once again get left behind and the digital divide will only grow more pronounced it the coming years.”

Also weighing in during the seven-day comment period was the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW), a national organization that “represents approximately 36,000 permanent employees working for telecommunications companies as well as thousands of construction workers who perform contract work for internet service providers.”

IBEW is against awarding LEO any BSLs, “IBEW believes that selecting either of those companies would be the wrong choice. The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law requires BEAD funds to only be used on projects that provide minimum broadband speeds of 100 Mbps download/20 Mbps upload, which is the FCC’s definition of broadband. According to a recent [Ookla Speedtest study], only 17.4% of SpaceX subscribers in the United States had broadband speeds meeting this requirement.”

Ultimately, SpaceX is claiming that “The Final Proposal is a manufactured outcome that is incompatible with the law and results in grossly wasteful and unnecessary costs to the taxpayer,” and insisting “Virginia must immediately revise its final proposal to appropriately consider applications received in line with program rules. Alternatively, NTIA must deny Virginia’s final proposal.”


SpaceX’s comments to Virginia’s Draft Final Proposal.

SpaceX Comments to VA Final Proposal (Final).pdf