Virginia vs. NTIA over BEAD rate regulation requirement
There’s an interesting and perhaps inevitable clash happening between the state (er, Commonwealth) of Virginia and the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), the federal agency in charge of administering BEAD.
As Route Fifty reported earlier this week:
In order to be approved to receive the first batch of its $1.4 billion in Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment, or BEAD funding, NTIA said Virginia—which only calls for companies to provide an “affordable” option—has to set an “exact" limit on how much companies can charge low-income households…
In its response, the state told NTIA that it does not believe it would be legal for states to tell companies how much they can charge, or for the agency to tell them to do so.
“Virginia is concerned that it is being asked by the funding agency, NTIA, to take an action that NTIA is expressly prohibited from taking,” wrote the Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development, which runs the state’s broadband, in a letter to the agency.We
We previously noted Route Fifty’s older reporting that several BEAD Initial Proposals from states including California, Massachusetts, Ohio, and Washington included caps of $30 per month or less for BEAD-funded low income plans, which is opposed by House Republicans and the telecom industry. But in an FAQ released in November 2023, NTIA maintained that “setting a cost to the consumer (or using a formula) for low-cost service offerings” is allowed, and expounded on this:
“Acceptable approaches to satisfy this requirement include, but are not limited to, offering a definition that establishes a specific dollar figure, a formula that would yield a firm dollar figure, a range of figures, a mechanism that would tie cost to an objective benchmark, or a set ceiling below which variation is permissible. These figures can be statewide of cover subdivisions of the state…In all cases, the definition must allow the Assistant Secretary to determine the expected cost to an Eligible Subscriber. Initial Proposals that do not comply with this requirement will not be approved”
Yet the QA doc also states: “The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law (BIL) states that NTIA is not authorized to regulate broadband rates. NTIA has not, and will not, engage in rate regulation.”
Instead, it seems, the agency wants the states to do the regulating, and is holding up funds if they don’t. Thoughts, VA folks? @Jeff Conner, @Charles Thomas, @Christina Kinne, @Jonathan Peter, @Derek Kelly, @Julie Kaylor, @KEITH WALKER, @Tamarah Holmes?